A dark twist on the Alice in Wonderland tales, this game is filled with unnerving images. Scariness: 4/10.
7 - Catherine
The game definitely can be very creepy at times, especially the haunting hand that chases you during the dream puzzles. Scariness: 5/10
6 - Dead Island
Zombies are always scary, even if they are in a tropical paradise. Scariness: 6/10
Made by Suda 51, this game has plenty of demons to spare. Scariness: 6.5/10.
4 - Dark Souls
A crazy difficult game that also is very creepy. Scariness: 7/10.
3 - Dead Space 2
The spookiness has definitely been upped in the sequel to the original Dead Space. Scariness: 8.5/10.
2 - F.3.A.R.
The third installment of the horror series, F.3.A.R. does not relent with shocks and scares. Scariness: 9/10.
Although this game came out last year, it was released for retail in North America this year. That still counts, right? Oh well, this game is one of the scariest games made, and deserves a spot on this list. Scariness: 11/10.